Nathan, the site looks great, and from what I know of true amateur porn lovers they are going to go crazy over this site. Those really into the 100% amateur niche can't get enough of this stuff.
Having said that.....I also know amateur performers, and the idea of making money doing something they can do at home and something they enjoy gives them the feeling of having their own company almost and many of them will really want to make a go of this and do it right to bring in some $$'s. I don't really think that downloading a model release and signing it, as well as providing copies of their ID's are a big deal to them. Yes, it may be a hassle, but honestly, once you start and work with the same performers on an ongoing basis, it just becomes routine.
Having this documentation will make the US webmasters feel "safer" Even though you don't need it legally where you reside, U.S. webmasters are going to feel much safer promoting sites that are 2257 compliant.
Being compliant also gives you a measure of protection, because you don't want fat old Uncle Bob suing the crap out of you or causing you problems because he had no idea that the chick that picked him up was going to post the video they made together all over the net.
It is something to think about, yes, I understand that some videos you have will not be useable, but I believe you will never have a shortage of people willing to provide you with the documentation you need in order to make some $$'s doing what they enjoy.
As for the person saying that they believed it was pricey, for some, yes it may be, but those that are very into this niche, the pricing will not stop them, especially when they get that all important personal touch from the performers.
Best of luck to you
