View Single Post
Old 07-26-2007, 12:59 AM  
Troels
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Between the clouds
Posts: 1,035
I'm in Europe so haven't been able to contribute.

But I read through all the posts, and I have to point out again that most of the pro-global warming people are resorting to the same accusation pointed out in the film (I won't call it documentary since you frown on that word):

You take the elitist condescending approach and call us skeptics less intelligent than you.

So at least the film was right about that claim...

Another claim from the film. Co2 is not causing global temperature rise, global temperature rise is causing co2 levels to rise. That's supported by IPCC which is the group of scientist everyone is quoting. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gre...arming_Swindle)

As far as I can tell pro-warming advocates are saying that the human caused extra co2 emissions MIGHT push the natural co2 balance into a snowball effect Earth can't recover from. Meaning that the higher co2 levels will cause the greenhouse effect and more water vapour will get into the atmosphere => more co2 leading to a unstoppable Venus scenario.

Again, the film and IPCC are both saying historically Co2 hasn't caused global temperature rise, it's the other way around probably because of increased water vapour. The film then says that human "contribution" is so small compared to natural effects that it's not nearly as dramatic as Al Gore etc is claiming, so a Venus-like effect is very very unlikely.

A lot of if's and maybe's for us skeptics I guess.

I still think the film was very interesting, and it seems a lot "facts" about global warming presented by the media today aren't that factual at all.
__________________
These guys steal your signups: Read here.
And sexsearch.com profit from it.
Check out which sponsors pay thieves here.
And here's a list of clean sponsors.

Last edited by Troels; 07-26-2007 at 01:01 AM..
Troels is offline   Share thread on Digg Share thread on Twitter Share thread on Reddit Share thread on Facebook Reply With Quote