Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
this is the big difference napster was illegal because the knowing violation happened on the sharing side (you lied about having a right to share) and the tracker in that case facilated that fraudlent claim.
........
the trackers are basically saying here is a person who has a right to the file (which the original seeder has to have since how else would he get the file) ask him for a piece if you have a right to the file.
only the lying downloader is guilty of a copyright infringement.
|
Yes... everyone now that has the file has it legally and only the receiver is getting it illegally. That makes sense.
Hmmmmmmmm... perhaps that little thing that says rebroadcasting my content without my express permission has something to do with this.... NO WAIT.. the guy you are sharing with has access to my site as well.. he is also a current member.. but it is easier to get it from you than from me.. yeah that's it.
NO WAIT... you are both former members that forgot to save my content and you are just using your fair usage rights to get the content from some kindly soul that is sharing it only with people that deserve to have it. Yeah that's it.. that's the ticket.
the trackers are saying here is a person who has the right to the file legally??? How the hell do they know that?