Quote:
Originally Posted by will76
you smoking crack. So you think if someone goes to a movie theatre and tapes a movie then uploads it, that it isn't theft?
|
most countries have laws that make the act of recording the movie in the theatre illegal so that is a crime
is it the crime of theft NO
Quote:
|
they didn't go steal the movie and give it to others?
|
steal no
give it away depends on how they upload it
in the torrent enviroment no they did not give anyone the movie they gave each person a small portion of the movie in an unviewable format.
Quote:
|
It was fair use, they had every right to do that. If that's your belief don't bother responding, you are a waste of time.
|
it completely depends on if the laws of the country allow the recording of the movie while in the theatre if you live in a country where that is a crime then the recording is in and of it self not authorized.
you can't claim fair use right of backup to content you don't have a right to view. and since the act of recording it would be illegal you can't /was not granted a right to view that copy.
ergo no fair use.
This is the BS i keep talking about
you can't argue against what i am actually saying so you pretend i am saying something else to try and make a point you don't have a right to make.