There's too much going on and it distracts the reader. Shorten the page so you can increase clickthroughs. Also, prioritize the stories based on CTR (there's scripts that do this). Add an email collection system. Dial down the ads a bit because it gets in the way of readability.
Also, change your URL structure/permalinks so it's more SE-friendly. For more SE traffic, create a lot of reference pages -- maybe biographies of wrestlers, wrestling events background information, information on wrestling movies. Key these towards searched keywords and subkeywords.
Email me if you need a ton of custom mainstream content for dirt cheap --
[email protected] or visit
http://www.webmasterlabor.com