Quote:
Originally Posted by sortie
Which one of those can you write/record/produce and sell?
If your answer is none, then consider that you may not know what is
required to do either and thus not trully able to determine their merit.
|
you're an idiot - really.
one doesn't need to be able to do something to be able to critique it and surely not to have an opinon about it - does the world's top wine critics grow grapes and make wine? does the literary critic write novels and sell them? does the movie critic produce movies?
no. and a critic is better when he does not attempt to - because then he begins to sympathize and his critques get skewed by 'i know how hard it is, so i will cut this movie some slack since i know i couldn't have made it better myself'