Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
you got it right
like i keep saying
leave the trackers alone
leave the seeders alone
leave the leachers who have a fair use alone
go after the leachers who don't have a fair use right (this is the only group committing piracy).
|
The problem is you seem to think everything is fair use. Earlier in the thread I posted that The Pirate Bay had the Woverine movie on it before it was even in theaters. You actually said that downloading a workprint was "fair use". You actually said, "fair use is an affirmative defence, you need to accused of something to be able to argue your actions are not an infringement because of fair use
using wolverine (work print) as proof of no fair use presuposes that the fair use right of access shifting would not be recognized (Which most certainly would have covered an unreleased work print)."
When I read it over again I can't really tell what you are saying. It is all some kind of double talk.
So please clarify for me by answering these two questions.
1. Is downloading the work print of Wolverine fair use?
2. Now The Pirate Bay has torrents up for the actual Wolverine movie. This movie is available in theaters only so you can't be downloading a backup of something you have already paid for. Is downloading this movie a copyright violation?