View Single Post
Old 08-19-2009, 11:30 AM  
dyna mo
The People's Post
 
dyna mo's Avatar
 
Industry Role:
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: invisible 7-11
Posts: 65,175
Quote:
Originally Posted by ModelPerfect View Post
Well, I suspect it wouldn't have worked out that way. The humans wanted to use the technology and was testing every alien artifact they could find. Even if the didn't know the transformation effect of the fluid, they likely would have kept the fluid for further studies, and being that it took twenty years to find the materials and process, then that's quite a gamble to take. Since his people had been mistreated and stuck in concentration camps, I think he'd realize the humans wouldn't say, "That one once of fluid can power that massive ship carrying 1.6 million prawns through the galaxy for at least 1.5 years; that's cool, and we have absolutely no interest in it, so we'll just let you walk away with it and supply you with enough food to feed 1.6 million prawns for that 1.5 years! No problem!" There's just no way that would have happened, and I think he'd have figured that out...
it's a movie, they can make it end however they want, just like how they made the alien benevolent in regards to the protagonist. those issues you mention are all easily dealt with in one way or another to allow act 3 to flow with acts 1 & 2.

but it remains that they built the alien up into a hero and let him bail on the rest, a plot hole based on setting up a sequel.
dyna mo is offline   Share thread on Digg Share thread on Twitter Share thread on Reddit Share thread on Facebook Reply With Quote