Hey Scott. I like you. You are a good guy and I really hope this kicks ass for you.
The idea is unique. I give you credit for coming up with something very different from what everyone is doing. I also like how you built up the anticipation on GFY that was great
That said you are asking for feedback. If I made the post I'd want honest feedback as much as it would hurt. I don't think this will be a smashing hit. I'm sure there is a community around the concept I just don't think it's being executed properly.
- The design is too old school. It looks like a 2001 AVS page. As a surfer I wouldn't sign up because I'd think it hasn't been updated since 2001.
- The girls just don't work. 2009/2010 we live in the world of Facebook girls. Ex Gf sites capitalize on that. The girls on your site look like 2001 porn girls. Not girls that can help.
- The videos are brutal. Not sexy or enticing or informative imo. Again looks too dated.
btw I haven't read any other feedback. Just giving my 2 cents.
I hate to knock an attempt at something new. I just think the execution as it is right now isn't what it needs to be to succeed. Your market is going to be tube traffic. This will not convert tube traffic imo.