the cintiq definitely rocks but it really all depends on your skills.. if you got 20 years of drawing routine, you can do the same with ye olde broke 1st generation tablet thingy.
re the original question: personally, i first draw a few mockups using pen and paper.. doodling around.. but i won't scan 'em.. once i have the final concept in mind, i start from scratch - digitally.
__________________
|