Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
first of all fair use supercede copyright violations specifically because of the notwithstanding clause and the explict declaration that fair use is not a copyright violation
which means your statement is totally wrong
if you ment to say that pink visual has proof that it is not fair use and therefore it is a direct copyright violation (which it seems to be based on your next statement ) then that a different issue
|
First of all.... fair use is "claimed" by someone, and the other party claims Copyright Violations... That's how it "actually" works.
They do have proof it's not fair use... ignored take down requests is a copyright violation even if a user uploaded it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
based on their public statement they are going after brazzers for providing a service that facilitates the fair use of commentary for people who BOUGHT pink visual content.
so either they ARE trying to stomp all over the fair use of commentary with a bitch move lawsuit
or
|
Based on the public statement they are suing them for several copyright violations.
Fair use/time shifting - would be users uploading it because they purchased a membership... that isn't what is happening.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
they are trying to destroy fair use of commentary by spread fud with a bogus claim in the press and winning it with a real arguement (like undeniable proof that brazzers employees uploaded the content with express written consent from all the board of directors of brazzers)
either way my comment still stands
i hope they get their ass handed to them
if they had the undeniable proof of knowing and authorized infringement they should be publicly sticking to those facts not trying to FUD against the fair use right of commentary.
|
You sue for every reason you can to make sure one sticks.... that's how it works.
It is a violation of fair use, "users" didn't upload it.. it's the same user on the site - that's before discovery of IP's - you can see that.
Either way, even IF someone did upload it, when you ignore a take down notice - it's a copyright violation.
Soooooo at the end of the day, Gideon supports Piracy over fair use. That's what your statement is saying.. no wonder most people on here hate you and...
...I understand now why you don't come to shows. Big man on the board, no balls in real life.