Quote:
Originally Posted by kane
If I want to put the parking break on my car and drive is slowly down the road that should be up to me to do. You are free to do with your car as you wish. I'm not stopping you. I'm not telling you what to do, I just want the right to do what I feel is best for me and not be forced to do things I might not want to do.
|
but that my arguement
i never said the copyright holder had be be forced to deliver it on every medium
i said they shouldn't have the right to prevent anyone who want to deliver on a medium they don't want to support
Quote:
|
I never said anything about selling you a car and telling you what you could do with it. If I sell you a car I don't care if you fuck it in the muffler. But my car is mine and I should be allowed to dictate how it is used.
|
sure you are
we are talking about STOPPING people from putting it on the torrents.
fair use doesn't force you do anything with your content
fair use simply takes away your right to stop people from doing what they want with the content they bought.
Quote:
|
Fair use, as you see it, means that if I decide not to release my movie in every possible format in every possible market then you should be allowed to download it and view it without paying since I didn't provide you with a way to conveniently view it.
|
copyright allows you to make the sale for the content in every medium
if you decide not to make the sale in a medium then there is no sale to be lost
so yes that is correct
Quote:
|
I disagree with that. I think fair use does as it says and it allows some people to use small parts of it for news, study, parody etc, but it doesn't mean that I should be forced to provide everyone with a my product when they want it in whatever format they want it or risk losing money to them just taking it.
|
your not forced to provide it in all formats