Quote:
Originally Posted by CrkMStanz
nice try Giddyboy
The Cablevision copy is not available to the general public
as usual - you try and use an example that does not address the subject
the cloud/torrent/fileshare thing allows anyone to access it
Cablevision plan = PRIVATE backup/timeshifting and should be allowed
cloud... et.al. = PUBLIC backup/timeshifting and should not be allowed
why can't you tell the difference?
 |
read the case again no where did it say anything about keeping the data private was necessary for cablevision to be allowed to do what they were doing
the cloud in the spec included the public internet as well.
the only key point that is relevent is that public transmission (some of which is thru the public internet) is not public broadcast.
i had this arguement before with Nautilus when i first talked about this case and when thru all the details there, i am not going to waste my time doing it again in another thread.
http://www.gofuckyourself.com/showth...a+cloud&page=4
http://gofuckyourself.com/showthread...s-cloud&page=2
read the full thread and then come back and talk.