It is prob better to go with anything.com than a .org as you will be building for the .com owner. But yes indeed in the SE's I see differently so those are two opposing views for you to chew on.
Everything is good. There are some funky .com domains getting serious traffic so domain is all about branding and describing your content if you plan on building an actual site. So why do that for the .com owner. That is the old school view and I tend to be in that camp.
But the guy with footcravings.org in the SERPs may feel diff.
Shouts to Silvercash: Still bringing in signups
Just had one for $25 big ones console free to footcravings.
An oldy but goody.