OK, I admit I'm no tin this field to know the ins and outs of DMCA - never said I did, but the hosting analogy seems wrong. If I was doing something illegal with my server, the ISP would be the first to know and they'd shut me off, right? I then went back to that ISP and got a new server and did the same, they'd shut me off again. The third time, they'd probably not take my business at all since they knew I was only in it to do things illegally.
Same with the law of my land and
ADOPI.