Originally Posted by Sarah_MaxCash

This year has actually been good because they had actual musicians on it. I loved Casey.

I do not 'get' Haley at at all. I don't think she even has that great a voice

Scotty is the answer to 'idol' out of the three of them. Casey and James were the ones I would personally have listened to though and since I am not the demographic, that is probably why they aren't still in it.