Quote:
Originally Posted by Due
I'll write it slowly this time so it'll be easier for you to comprehend.
If your bringing nothing new to the table I'll just let you go on with your rampage.
Rambling on how dvd rippers and fair usage justifies your file sharing and now starting to call it public domain goes beyond me.
|
when your right from the very begining and your arguing with an idiot who keeps dancing around desperately to justify his position you have to keep going back to the same point
the court case proves my point so i keep going back too it.
you originally said
Quote:
The problem is usually that when you download it you share it hence you serve it to people who may not have paid for this tv show.
That's distribution of copyrighted material. Buying a TV show doesn't give you the right to share it.
|
i pointed out that was insanely stupid because
- seeder never gives away a complete working copy of the file,
- .5% of the swarm wouldn't have a right to the content and
- tcp/ip packets work on the same practise
so if you made the seeding of pieces to .5 % who didn't have a right voided the entire fair use right, you just destroyed the internet because copyright infringement happens because of tcp/ip too.
you have been dancing around making up more excuses to try and justify your bogus idea of copyright
now your trying to claim that you need control over the content in the swarm to have a fair use right.
that lack of control voids fair use
no where in the definition of fair use is control defined as a requrement
it the most insane arguement because your actually going against the very wording of the copyright act.
Quote:
In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include ?
(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
(2) the nature of the copyrighted work;
(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
(4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
|
nowhere whatsoever does it say anything about any type of personal control being required for a fair use to exist.
nowhere whatsoever does it say that it must be private for the fair use to exist
if it meets those 4 conditions PERIOD it fair use
and using the cloud to move the viewing time for content you purchased from monday to tuesday (timeshfiting using the cloud0 meets those 4 conditions to the exact same degree as using a vcr to move the viewing from monday to tuesday.