Quote:
Originally Posted by Cherry7
The quote was
"Karl Marx may have been wrong about communism"
and that is what I disputed. He did not write a "plan for communism" which did not work and therefore he got it wrong.
He did no such thing, and he may a point of it.
If you read Isaac Deutschers trilogy on Trotsky he describes vividly the debate on how to built a new society and how little there was to go on in 1919...
Culture is not the property of the ruling classes, in trade unions rudeness to fellow workers is not allowed. But behave like an idiot if it suits you.
As you know nothing about me your remark is stupid.
|
So can you give us an example of where Communism works please.
Capitalism is by no means perfect, but it works. For some badly, for other OK, for a very few very well.
Communism worked for no one but the Autocrats at the top. When I first arrived here everyone thought that if you drove a decent car, you were a party official of Mafia. When we arranged a Christmas dinner for the family, Eva's parent arrived at the 4 star hotel saying they didn't belong in such a place.
They had been programmed to think that way by the so called "Peoples Party".
Give us one example of where Communism has worked. Or do you think we should all toss out a system that does work in favor of one that never worked?
"Culture is not the property of the ruling classes" It was in Communist countries.