I always liked the Tivo interface, but it was hooked to a phone line(do they still do that?) and it didn't feel integrated with my system. I had to switch to another TV input, etc.
The Cable DVR interface isn't as nice, but it feels more organic to the cable box and TV, and everything is right there without having to go through any steps -- and I don't need the extra "Tivo" box taking up space. Actually, I remember throwing my Tivo in the dump, and it wasn't a major decision to do it. It just got tossed out with some old computer cases and other debris.
So, I like the DVr better.
__________________
|