Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
I said YOU are making misleading claims that the internet will be "broken" by this legislation.
|
Gosh this is tiresome. I based my *opinion* on reading the articles from the DNS experts.
I linked you to the site where the experts explained the problems with the DNS part of SOPA.
Would you like to explain why they are wrong?
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
Can you understand my point ?
|
Yes. Your point is that you think *I* am a DNS expert and wrote articles explaining why the DNS issues with SOPA are very dangerous?
Good point! This is awesome fun.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
No one knows because the Chinese will never allow that type of information to be released.
|
How do you imagine they would *get* this information? How does a government measure the impact of sites with pirated content on exactly? Do you think the file locker sites just tell them?
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
Thats not me telling you what you do or don't know
|
No, that isn't, but the part where you said I didn't know something was.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
I am just pointing out the the inadequacies of your argument.
|
Well, you are desperately trying to, but you're not really doing it very well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
Lets be clear here Damian you brought up China as an example of how they have instigated similar legislation "Look, China already has THIS censorship" you cheerfully claimed.
|
No I didn't. I said they have a firewall and it doesn't work. Really, try quoting what I say, then attempting your counterpoint. It makes it much more cohesive.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
You used China as an example of why SOPA wont "work".
|
No I didn't. Really, quote what I say.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
Or are you now agreeing that comparisons with SOPA and the Chinese legistlation is really rather silly ?
|
You made that comparison. I said China had internet censorship. Do keep up.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
With regards to history proving there is no solution to piracy. Jesus. Technological innovation is not about history. It is about the present and the future.
|
It is totally about history. Since the dawn of mankind piracy has been unstoppable. Then the digital age came along and it is now REALLY VERY unstoppable.
Do you seriously, honestly, in your heart of hearts think that someone will come up with something and all the pirates will just go "ok, that's us done". You don't think they will change? You don't think they will just create another internet? Seriously?
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
and should the laws which put the forgers in prison be rescinded because they do not "work" ?
|
I never said to rescind laws because they don't work. There is a law against copyright infringement. There should be. Please, quote what I say rather than waste time making facetious points about stuff no one said.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
Give it up Damian, your arguments are preposterus.
|
And yet you cannot actually make a SINGLE counterpoint to ONE of them. So go figure.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewNick
The free ride for thieves might not be eradicated by this legislation. But you have not offered a reasoned argument as to why you think that is.
|
All you need is the pure IP.
Please provide your counterpoint as to why that is wrong. (This should be good for a laugh...)
Then (for bonus points) go on to explain why it is a good idea for
1) your competition to be able to get your site shut down in 5 days with no judicial process or proof
2) to allow the US government to censor the internet
And then tell me if you honestly think this bill will have any impact whatsoever on adult website revenue and why.