Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
Then educate me explain to me how the statement this is the coolest dance routine i have ever seen is valid commentary when done in my home
yet using the medium of a tube site is not.
remember that copyright holders argued that they provided a medium of timeshifting (re runs) and argued that second medium (betamax tapes) was invalid too.
Explain exactly why saying a medium makes it illegal this time, remember you can't use the lose of revenue (since that didn't work in the vcr example) or the profits YOUTUBE is making (see vcr case).
|
Your definition of "fair use" in your other post reads like this :
"It's fair for 1,000,000 people to jack off at home alone, therefore it's the same for
one guy to jack off 1,000,000 people in public.
