My cat just caught the same baby rabbit for the third time in the past two days - at least I think it's the same, same size, same general vicinity. Thankfully she hasn't yet harmed it that I can see. I hope that it's the same one, otherwise that would indicate there is a clutch under my porch which means it's going to keep happening until the mother, if she's still around, decides to move them.
And my cat can be a total pain in the ass when she wants to go outside (she's smart AND tenacious, which makes her very annoying when she sets her heart on something) so keeping her inside indefinitely is not a viable solution.
The funny thing is that the first time I did not want to touch it as I kept thinking of that guy that got the plague trying to get the mouse out of the stray cat's mouth. Still, I think I'll go wash my hands now.