Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
Yes because Cooper is an ex Nasa pilot, Because Cooper followed the coordinates and clues, because his daughter finally changed his mind and proved that something more was going on in the library.
|
I still think it's lazy story telling on Nolan's part IMO
Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
I would have preferred a little more story here too. It would have been nice to see more of Nasa, to see more training, more build up, etc etc. Then again it's already an almost 3 hour movie so maybe this had to be trimmed out. I wouldn't mind seeing an extended cut on Blu Ray....
|
I think it's a shame that films have to last for a set amount of time,
If it takes 4 - 4.5 hours to make the film into the great film it should have been then so be it!
Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
I think you're being too hard on this movie. Sure its not perfect and I have my own problems with the movie (How could they be drinking beer on the porch if all the hops are gone? Ok maybe beer is just more expensive or maybe they had a stash, but still. And where in the future is this movie? Judging by all the pickup trucks and cars it looks like "today", but these are minor.
|
See I disagree, Christopher Nolan is an outstanding talent. Instead of praising a mediocre film I think fans should be critical if it's warranted and in the case of this film I feel it is.
I'll watch it again like I have done with all his other films, this one isn't a 10/10 and I expect that from Nolan hence the disappointment.
Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
Ok, but any movie can be pulled apart. Relax a little and try to enjoy the story.
|
See I disagree, the outstanding films cannot be picked apart easily because they are of the highest quality. Perhaps I am being too harsh but it's only because I expected better from Nolan
Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
Me too. I love all of his movies and I especially love GOOD "Real" [SCIENCE] Fiction and when I go nuts for a movie, holes in plot or goofs in physics can take me out of the movie.
|
A film has failed to impress me if I'm finding plot holes or thinking about how a scene could have been better.
Quote:
Originally Posted by **********
On a side note, I love the Back to the Future movies. Sure you can argue that Doc Brown's time machine doesn't have enough energy or mass to travel through time but it doesn't matter. The Flux Capacitor and some Plutonium is all that he needs. |
Fair point
