Originally Posted by k0nr4d

Absolutely the 2011 in this case. The 2012 has no navigation/idrive, so immediately you will feel like you are driving a cheaper car + will be harder to sell later. That missing headlight sprayer panel is a bit suspicious, paired with those headlights (only m-package - which this car does not have - has white LED rings, other ones have yellow - at least in europe) so it might have been hit somewhere in the front.