Quote:
Originally Posted by kane
Correct me if I am wrong, but didn't he once say that McElfresh asked him to have sex with his daughter while he watched and Donny turned him down? Not it sounds like he is saying that never really happened, but McElfresh's daughter was threatening to say it did.
|
Yes that's what Sarrettah pointed out - this is what happens when you lie a lot, you forget exactly what you've lied about before and your new lies inevitably contradict the old lies ending up with nobody, other than your mother possibly, having any reason to believe anything you say.
Donny told the TV reporter unequivocally that McElfresh asked him to have sex with McElfresh's daughter in front of him. Now here he is today saying that McElfresh's daughter 'claimed' that her father had Donny have sex with her in front of him.
Now that I read it again I can foresee what Donny's rebuttal to this will be, he will maintain that the daughter's claim that Donny had sex with her is a lie, which lets him stick to the story that the father did ask him to have sex with her but he refused. He uses the word 'claim', implying she was telling a lie, only with respect to him having sex with the girl, not that there wasn't a proposition made to him by the father.
So riddle me this - how in the world after Donny rejects the idea of fucking the daughter does the daughter come up with this same exact scenario to tell the police? There's only two reasonable possibilities -
1) the captain told her he wanted to watch her have sex with Donny before asking Donny, she was up for it, but Donny rejected the offer
OR
2) she's not lying, she did have sex with Donny while the father watched and masturbated
"When he (the bf) finally got out of jail, she took him to talk to her dad. He (the bf) recorded a conversation where she claimed several threatening things, including the claim that he (the captain/dad) had me have sex with her while he (the captain/dad) watched and masturbated.She definitely slept with a lot of people while her boyfriend was in jail, but I was not one of them. However, Captain McElfresh was petrified of being accused of such charges so he gave her what she wanted and let her and her boyfriend do whatever they wished."
I believe it's the second but with the trash involved in this story who knows. McElfresh is guilty, both the daughter and Donny have fingered him as the orchestrator of at minimum the proposition that Donny have sex with his 16 year old daughter in front of him.