galleryseek

Funny, I just read a retort to this silly argument earlier today. Enjoy...

"If you think you'd be better off without any government, you should try living a year or so in the ungoverned parts of Somalia, Yemen, or Iraq."

It's been too long since I've encountered the "If you like Anarchy move to Somalia" fallacy so I'm delighted to entertain it.

1) The irony of citing war torn or economically unstable regions due to corrupt government ruling classes and sociopathic dictators cannot be overstated. In order to understand the solution one must first understand basic definitions. A State is a monopoly on violence over a given geographical region financed by the theft of taxation and legitimized by the belief in authority. Man made law is an opinion backed by a gun. Politicians are sociopathic megalomaniacs with an insatiable appetite to control peaceful people. Legality is diametrically opposed to morality. Regulations strangulate voluntary peaceful interactions. The chaos you are referring to can only result from the violent centrally planning of the State, or abrupt lack thereof.

"The beginning of wisdom is to call things by their proper name." Confucius

2) Anarchy and Voluntaryism are firmly rooted in principles of universal morality and self responsibility. Just as murdering all the bishops, cardinals, and priests in a theocratic state will not produce a population who philosophically understand atheism; so too simply removing or murdering all the politicians and bureaucrats will not produce a population who philosophically understand Voluntaryism and Anarchy. The focus must always be on educating the minds of the people. They must abandon their delusions that putting the very worst scum into positions of great power will yield positive results. That which can only be achieved through coercion is morally wretched and is already destined for miserable failure. Good ideas do not require force. Thoughts are several magnitudes more powerful than guns or tanks.

"You need power only when you want to do something harmful, otherwise love is enough to get everything done." Charlie Chapin

3) It claims that the gang of liars, thieves, and murderers that comprise the U.S. Federal government legitimately own the entire geographical region known as the United States of America. To my knowledge, property can be acquired one of four ways; Homesteading model, Economic model, Inheritance Model, and the Mafia model. The Homesteading model indicates mixing one's labor with the land or delineating one's ownership by means of a border that one can successfully defend. This often is associated with being the first person to use the land. The Economic model is purchasing a piece of land through voluntary trade that was previously owned by someone else. The Inheritance model is being gifted the land by the previous owner. The Mafia model is acquired through theft, coercion, and the threat of violence. Which model do you think the State uses?

"All legit property is private. If property isn't private it's stolen." Gustave de Molinari