Originally Posted by LAJ

I think there's enough music aficionados here to chime in on this...

Taking EVERYTHING into account...

- raw musical talent
- stage presence
- chemistry among members
- no weak link members
- core members remaining the same
- sheer number of hits vs. filler
- longevity
- music style
- personal style
- timing in history
- personality
- behavior / antics / excess offstage
- innovation
- commercial success
- other bands who consider them an influence
- overall legacy to this day

Who would be #1 in your eyes?

I think most bands that would fit all of these categories would be from the 60s / 70s... But Led Zeppelin ultimately wins.