I do not think it's wrong, but it's not my flavor. Exit only, poop dick, whatever some of the stereotypes are. But I have plenty of friends who talk about it like it's the second coming.
My guess, from their stories, is they are pinners and need something 'tighter'. Every person I've heard who likes anal says something to the effect of it being like a virgin pussy (super tight). I've had my share of virgins over the years, and I can't say fucking a virgin potatoe sack was anything marvelous. But that's just me.
All that said, if it turns their crank so be it. However, when I've met women into anal, I ended up breaking it off. They tend to not like their toes sucked, and prefer anal over the front door. Which is not my flavor, and I have no interest in trying it for the sake of getting them off.
I guess it just comes down to compatability.
