IP-Address Can?t Even Identify a State, BitTorrent Judge Rules
 

http://torrentfreak.com/ip-address-c...-rules-120515/

so these lawsuits don't even have enough evidence to establish jurisdiction.

Freetard idiot.

You are so late. I thought you would've jumped on this like a vampire on a virgin, but - NO - you missed the boat. Again.

Oh, too late. So sorry. Fuck off, try again next time. See you soon!

Buh-bye!

That's kind of hot.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-VDI56R7TGB...%2BVampire.jpg

so if i am freetard idiot because i think shoddy evidence of guilt is excluded

does that mean you support kiddie porn distribution because you objected to you getting convicted for sending hits to nasty dollars.

some will say it's ok, some will say ip address is shit as evidence...

it the geolocation that the issue.

something that has 20-50% chance of being wrong should never be used as the basis for a court case.

you want to get by this first stage invest a couple billion dollars in making geo location accurate to a city block.

AFAIK it never is used as the basis for a court case. It is used to get addresses to send extortion letters.

but the claim to get the info is based on the arguement they are going forward with a court case.

Breaking news: Proxies hide your location.

The ruling doesn't say can't. It says may not. If it couldn't, then no police could solve any internet crimes.

Indeed, but I don't think they ever do. Certainly none of the ACS:Law cases here did.

Its great to see all these loop holes and "freedom of speech" crap costing the entertainment industry billions of $$$ and the pirates being smug about it. Its the best wind in the sails that nazi laws like SOPA and PIPA need :1orglaugh

Enjoy while it lasts :1orglaugh

I don't see the problem with the filing of lawsuits requiring a substantial level of evidence...

yeah how dare we have "loop holes" like presumption of innocents

and an expectation that people accusing at use tools that accurately identify you.

Seriously all copyright holders should be allowed to go after people with tools so substandard that they are wrong 20-50% of the time.

http://www.ankurb.info/wp-content/up...rcasm-sign.png

noone likes a thief cunt

Good Lord....gideon "freeloader" gallery is STILL coming on GFY and posting?

Does anybody wonder why he does that? He isn't in this business. He doesn't have any friends on here. He's never met one person from this forum. He only posts things that HURT our business.

Look gideongallery....you can post whatever cherry-picked rulings that are posted on your beloved torrent (pirate) sites all you want.
But here's a newsflash for ya: You can absolutely be FOUND via your IP address.

You might think you can't...but there are plenty of smart people who can pierce right through the veil of proxy servers and find you. The FBI does it all the time...and they are hardly the sharpest cookies in the box.

But again...WHY does gideongallery post on GFY? What drives him to do so? It's like a guy who has been thrown out of a bar and nobody wants him there or likes him...but he INSISTS on coming back in and starting a fight.

You are a deluded, lonely, sick human being gideongallery.

Please do society a favor and go get a job.

This cartoon reminds me of Gideon.

http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/duty_calls.png

Gideon clearly has a personality disorder that can't let him rest until everyone agrees with him.

I still love how douchebags like Robbie still think that because of his stance on torrents you all think he is pro piracy and call him a thief ad nauseaum. Not ONE SINGLE TIME has he ever said this or even insinuated it. Bunch of fucking morons if you ask me.

You guys have called him a thief. I don't think anyone here could back that up with proof.

This court case says that an ip address can not be used to establish jurisdiction in a state based civil actions

FBI stands for Federal Bureau of investigation

Jurisdiction issue != not being found at all.

how stupid do you have to be to not understand that simple point.

funny how the guy who jumps into every thread i post

is the guy who post this image.