I need help defining my niche.
 

So, MormonGirlz.com has been live for over a year now. There's been steady growth and, even though about six months ago I switched up the style of content (and significantly upped production value) my members have stayed loyal.

But sales are still relatively low. It's really niche and story based, but I'm finding it hard to attach my content to any particular search terms or porn categories.

Is it Older / Younger? Teen? Orgy? Lesbian? All of the above...

Is that a problem? Not sure how to proceed with SEO and targeting specific categories in my marketing.

Thoughts?

Did you try : religious porn, sacrilegious porn, taboo porn, stigma porn ?

I could label it that, but does anyone search for those things? Does those terms have trending / SEO power?

Leave the seo for tube owners. You focus to provide good content for them.

You are not going to rank too high with a very little content. Find website within your niche and invite them to your affiliate program.

Below is a snapshot of taboo porn for example.
plus what do you loose if you add those tags? besides, these tags are what describe your product. Wankers that are looking for religious porn may end up on your site. Isn't that what you want ?

taboo porn - matching keywords (for google.com database) y
Keyword
taboo porn
CPC
$1.80
Com.
0.00
Volume
74,000
Number of results
15,600,000