Palm Treo 700 vs. Motorola Q - which one would you take?
 

need a pda phone type thing, narrowed it down to the treo and the Q. any good/bad experiences with either of those?

I havent had 1 issue with my Q, love the phone. It has the best sound quality of any of the pda's out there

The Treo speaker blows often... I had to change mine twice... My wife owns a Q and no issues there.

I like the treo do cause of the touch screen ...

It all depends on what ou want to do really

I have a Treo 700p and I love it. :2 cents:

Looked at the 700 and the Q. Went with the Blackberry 8703! The thing is awesome, stable, and EASY to setup. :2 cents: Best of Luck on whatever you choose!

The Q is a Phone with PDA capabilities, while the Treo is a PDA with phone capabilities.

That's the setup the Verizon guy tried to use when selling me.

I went with the Treo. Also have a Blackberry and a PPC7600. Treo is my favorite.

i basically need it for email on the go, and the occasional excel spreadsheet. i like the treo because it is touch screen, but i like the q because it is so much thinner

for the Q owners, how is web browsing w/o having touch screen?

I like my treo 700wz

Blackberry.