Help me decide my new logo concept
 

I had two really cool looking concepts from a talented cartoonist. I am really stumped as to which one I should choose since I like them both. Which one do you prefer?

http://mrpinks.com/mrpinks_idea2.jpg

http://mrpinks.com/mrpinks_idea3.jpg

In case you're wondering, they are not the finished product as far as coloring. :winkwink:

They're both good. Use them both.

I thought about it but I would like to choose one.

#1 is too busy, #2 is much better

I like this one

http://mrpinks.com/mrpinks_idea3.jpg

2nd one gets my vote....

both of them really looks nice but i like the second one

2nd one.....

At first I was leaning more towards the first one but today I am really leaning towards the second one. Indecisive. That's why I started the thread.

I like 'em both also but 2 really catches my eye

Not sure if I like the genie deal on two. Is there anything I should have done to improve it? Would you change anything about it?

#2......I agree about the genie... change it just to a torso.... have it end at the cut of the pink box right about his waist.... see how it looks.

#2 is better :thumbsup

2nd one is way better imo

bottom one.

Hey, how busy is your cartoonist guy ? He work pro bono ? :)

Pro bono? No, but very reasonable. He's not an adult guy. I found him on a mainstream site. He does amazing shit. I'll ask him if he wants to do more work. Let me know if you want to contact him.

Here's the deal : I want a cartoon guy to do smallish (200x2-300 px) cartoons to break up some of my articles that are too wordy. He gets to choose which articles and what to make for em (within reason) and I'd give him linkage, make him a special about page, give him email addy that sorta stuff. Anything short of actually paying :)

Ask tho, maybe he's into it, the site's kinda cool and all.