Look stupid, you can't even come up with your own arguments. the best you can do is copy and paste links and not even discuss any meaning in what you posted.

masssa pleeeeaaase

Let me ask this again to people:

You really believe rich and powerful white people started the civil war to protect a bunch of black slaves?

THAT WAS THE TRUE REASON THAT YOU BELIEVE IN?

its pretty stupid to think those people are dead because of a flag, makes no sense.

taking away inanimate objects will never stop the ideology.

Interesting, the states rights to allow by law its landholding rich class to own other men's labors in servitude.

The Germans do not hold the Nazi flag as part of their glory the Japanese do not fly the rising sun battle flag of Japan. But for some reason in the USA the battle flag of the losers is admired by some ...

Some heritage ...

"possibly numerous reasons" how could there "possibly" be. You stopped short of saying there WERE numerous reasons.

How about rich and powerful white men wanting to keep control over a very rich and productive area through taxes. Wanting to enrich themselves. Hmmm no that wouldn't make much sense.

Instead it must be a group of rich and powerful white men (most likely extreme racists in the day) wanting to free a bunch of blacks. Ya ya that must be it...

Some of you people are hilarious. You create some fairy tale world in your brain and have 0 capability of seeing through smoke screens.

serious response:

no, i don't believe that was the reason. because that wasn't the reason. it wasn't to morally protect black slaves. it was to protect the economic and political systems of slavery.


and sure, there were secondary and tertiary reasons, militias, states rights, etc. but those also hinge around protecting the entrenched system.

Lets take your point a step further. To me it was basically economic terrorism against the south knowing full well the necessity of slaves to keep the farms churning which was the majority of their economy.

Cut off slavery, cut off huge parts of the economy, cut off their wealth and power. Thus making it easier to control them and bring them under the Unions umbrella.

Telling the population "we want to go to war to stop other Americans earning potential so we can control them" doesn't have as nice a ring as "liberty and freedom for all".

It is not about the slaves it was and IS always about CONTROL. Especially ECONOMIC CONTROL.

Tell the Jews they are pretty fucking stupid to care about a swastika that never killed them.

I bet you don't dare.

I bet you're scared shitless of Jews, you wouldn't flag a Nazi flag out of pure fear.


:1orglaugh

i don't disagree with the premise, except history shows this happened the other way around. the SOuth seceded on account of Lincoln's government, which didn't acknowledge the seccession, thus, the South then started the war.

here's the thing, this is the most complicated and controversial period in American history, this debate still lingers and i get that, historians have often times clouded the issue due to its' emotional impact and people identifying with their own groups.

I'm not trying to claim i'm right and you are wrong, but i had to clear up the personal slur that educated people would never think that slavery was the cause of the Civil War.

Something people are missing about that flag. I do 100% understand that it caries a lot of Negative thoughts and feelings with it because historically people have said the flag and the separation were for Slavery.

And yes that was one of the points of the break of the union but it was also for the idea of freedom and Autonomy from the Feds to have the RIGHT to have slaves and have the RIGHT to have state laws that either made it Legal or not.

I always think it's funny since they lost the war on slavery.

Shouldn't they be worshipping the white surrender flag?

they cut them up and made halloween costumes!!

http://madmikesamerica.com/wp-conten...11/02/sons.jpg
hotlinked

:2 cents::2 cents:

If it was a minority group you could easily reclaim the flag but....But a country with a culture is going to allow it.

...because it was a flag that killed them.

What the fuck, why for F sake is this thread on GFY??? and why didn´t any moderator delete this shit and dum dum so dum pics from this forum, you all have to be a shame of yourself being such dum, not educated and ignorant people, get a life!

yes those are the same people that believe Iraq war was about weapons of mass destruction :thumbsup

I'm not so sure about that one... it's an interesting argument however I'm sure the blacks don't identify as 'southern' or of being a part of 'southern culture' ....

I would say that the St Andrews cross is more a representation or statement of agrarian vrs industrial societies if anything....

and if you listen to country music, southern culture is defined by family, god and service to country as well as being a good ole boy or in general, a fuck head drunk, which goes back to Celtic culture....

if you actually believe the civil was about slaves then obviously you believe the Iraq war was about weapons of mass destruction...

or were you thinking the Sothern states were going to write 'the northern industrials paid off the Yankee politicians to take our money and use it for expansion in the west, so we quit fuck you....?

at some point you need to buy a vowel homy :helpme

:2 cents:

[QUOTE=L-Pink;20509659]You have lived in the south long enough to understand the mindset

That would require attending school and paying attention to their history classes; we both know that never happened