GoFuckYourself.com - Adult Webmaster Forum

GoFuckYourself.com - Adult Webmaster Forum (https://gfy.com/index.php)
-   Fucking Around & Business Discussion (https://gfy.com/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   creatine: i've gained 12+ pounds in 6 days, ugh, am i doing it wrong? (https://gfy.com/showthread.php?t=976195)

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgtarheels (Post 17302426)
Wait, now creatine doesn't bloat?


Lol...

no it does and shouldnt, if your bloating up your taking entirely too much of it. i find taking it on training days only after muscle saturation has occured works best for me. If your still having an issue on 5G's on training days only try a creatine ethyl ester like Green Mag by controlled labs

dyna mo 07-02-2010 12:17 PM

going over my food intake, i've increased carbs, the fibrous ones - grains, seeds, fruits, vegs. over the last week too eh. at least by 2x

Cyber Fucker 07-02-2010 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dyna mo (Post 17301651)
started the optimum nutrition micronized, instructions say to load up by taking 1 tspn 4x a day for 5 days.

did that and now i am completely bloated, distended gut, stomach is upset often. bodyfat hasn't increased but the bloating is severe. does that subside? what's the point.

Creatine is good muscle stimulant and protector but you need solid workout and good diet plan to do it right.

mgtarheels 07-02-2010 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302448)
no it does and shouldnt, if your bloating up your taking entirely too much of it. i find taking it on training days only after muscle saturation has occured works best for me. If your still having an issue on 5G's on training days only try a creatine ethyl ester like Green Mag by controlled labs

So, you bitch about people spreading misinformation, and you follow up by saying creatine doesn't bloat you up, and then with this comment? Lol, stop it.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Demon (Post 17302444)
The side effects of creatine include bloating and looking "thick". That usually happens when one doesn't drink enough water while loading on creatine.

creatine forces more water into the muscle cells not ontop of and inbetween muscle fibers, it will not take away from that shredded look unless your going out for a competition.

L-Pink 07-02-2010 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dyna mo (Post 17302390)
it's the #1 nutrient, but didn't y'all have to work up to that amount? i am making progress towards the 1 gallon a day, but i certainly can't just start drinking a gal+ a day.

I drink 2-3 1 liter bottles of S. Pellegrino water everyday. I no longer drink Cokes or beer and the carbonation doesn't make it seem like water. The rest is easy.


.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgtarheels (Post 17302456)
So, you bitch about people spreading misinformation, and you follow up by saying creatine doesn't bloat you up, and then with this comment? Lol, stop it.

ok ill run to the bathroom and take a picture of me and then post it and u can see how lean i am and tell me im bloated up...you do the same ok? and not for nothing but i said when you take TOO MUCH youll get bloated...reading comprehension > you.

mgtarheels 07-02-2010 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302464)
ok ill run to the bathroom and take a picture of me and then post it and u can see how lean i am and tell me im bloated up...you do the same ok?

You've already posted pics of yourself, not impressed.

And you =/= all.

Creatine can cause bloating, plain and simple. You're wrong.

dyna mo 07-02-2010 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mynameisjim (Post 17302447)
As was mentioned earlier, the "loading phase" is just from the old days. You don't need to do it anymore.

What you do want to do is take it post workout after something to spike your blood sugar for about 30 minutes. Dextrose works the best but regular grape juice works as well. Just drink it spread out over 30 minutes to keep your blood sugar spiked the whole time. You don't need to do it, but it helps get the creatine to the muscles, same with your post workout protien.

Creatine works different for different people and I think it has to do with how much meat you eat. I eat zero meat so it has a very noticeable effect for me and I use it daily. I can get several more sets out of each exercise when using creatine and you do get better pumps. People who eat a lot of meat sometimes don't see any results. But it all depends.

I would say stop taking it for a day or two to normalize out from that crazy loading phase then go to the daily 5 grams.

this is on point with how i am currently taking it. 5g pwo with my insulin spiking meal.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302448)
no it does and shouldnt, if your bloating up your taking entirely too much of it. i find taking it on training days only after muscle saturation has occured works best for me. If your still having an issue on 5G's on training days only try a creatine ethyl ester like Green Mag by controlled labs

since i'm doing the 6 day split, i can take it 6 days/ 1 day off eh?

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:23 PM

[QUOTE=mgtarheels;17302470]You've already posted pics of yourself, not impressed.

And you =/= all.[/QUOTE=mgtarheels;17302470]

that was about 4 months ago, im almost into single digit bf percentage at the same weight boss. IT CAN cause it im not saying it doesnt, but at the right dosage and with the proper amount of water it wont.
Dyna try 3g's a day everyday and see how that works out for you.

dyna mo 07-02-2010 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyber Fucker (Post 17302455)
Creatine is good muscle stimulant and protector but you need solid workout and good diet plan to do it right.

i'm pretty stoked with the wo/diet plan i'm on and totally agree.
Quote:

Originally Posted by L-Pink (Post 17302461)
I drink 2-3 1 liter bottles of S. Pellegrino water everyday. I no longer drink Cokes or beer and the carbonation doesn't make it seem like water. The rest is easy.


.

well, shit that's my prob, i'm trying it with tap water! :1orglaugh:1orglaugh:1orglaugh

L-Pink 07-02-2010 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dyna mo (Post 17302489)


well, shit that's my prob, i'm trying it with tap water! :1orglaugh:1orglaugh:1orglaugh

Tap water is too boring :winkwink:


.

mgtarheels 07-02-2010 12:26 PM

[QUOTE=DLXphil;17302484]
Quote:

Originally Posted by mgtarheels (Post 17302470)
You've already posted pics of yourself, not impressed.

And you =/= all.[/QUOTE=mgtarheels;17302470]

that was about 4 months ago, im almost into single digit bf percentage at the same weight boss. IT CAN cause it im not saying it doesnt, but at the right dosage and with the proper amount of water it wont.
Dyna try 3g's a day everyday and see how that works out for you.

You DID say it doesn't. Go back and read what you said.

YOU are the one spreading misinformation, not dyna.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:27 PM

the reason that many people think that mono causes bloating is that the mono is not taken up by the cells as completely as a product like creatine ethyl ester like i mentioned earlier. When creatine isnt taken up by the cells it stays in the spaces between cells and causes an imbalance that will hold water in that space. This his what causes the bloating, and this is from when you take too much. does that explain it good enough for you?

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:29 PM

[QUOTE=mgtarheels;17302498]
Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302484)

You DID say it doesn't. Go back and read what you said.

YOU are the one spreading misinformation, not dyna.

IT DOESNT AT THE PROPER DOSAGE! hes LOADING hes intaking 4 times the normal amount to saturate his cells of course theres going to be an osmotic gradient (water regulation ) in the cells that cause bloat.

mgtarheels 07-02-2010 12:30 PM

[QUOTE=DLXphil;17302518]
Quote:

Originally Posted by mgtarheels (Post 17302498)

IT DOESNT AT THE PROPER DOSAGE! hes LOADING hes intaking 4 times the normal amount to saturate his cells of course theres going to be an osmotic gradient (water regulation ) in the cells that cause bloat.

Who cares if he's loading or not? He's bloated. What from? CREATINE.

Plain and simple, connect the dots.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:32 PM

[QUOTE=mgtarheels;17302525]
Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302518)

Who cares if he's loading or not? He's bloated. What from? CREATINE.

Plain and simple, connect the dots.

yes bloated from overdosing...i can connect the dots. OK creatine does cause bloat in MEGA DOSES! Taken in a normal dosage scheme which hes not doing currently will yeild zero bloat

dyna mo 07-02-2010 12:32 PM

so i think i'll stop the creatine for 2 days, then dose a more reasonable 3g/day pwo days. and then reassess when the bottle runs out.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:33 PM

dyna you know whats up! btw, i got that 405x3 deadlift yesterday! felt so good to be back where i was 2 years ago! oh and before i forget, sometimes creatine will cause some unwanted gas too so u might also be feeling the effects of that. Are you taking a multi with zinc or magnesium?

Vjo 07-02-2010 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by riddler (Post 17301920)
its water weight, dont worry about it..

use it for a while to build up your beginner gains if you are just starting lifting then taper off and just supplement with good protein sources (lean meats).

and the gallon of water a day stuff is bro-science, you drink when you are thirsty all those idiots that drink a gallon+ a day are just over working their kidneys, you have a thirst mechanism for a reason.

Thank you. I have long suspected having to drink so much water when you arent thirsty is bs.

Now maybe drinking all that water does some good but yeah it does seem unnatural.

Everyone promoting anything health related has their own slant and line of bs to sell their product.

I take 1000 mg of chewable C and two chewable Active Kids vites a day. Easy and covers ya.

I used to take all the vites. 16 to 20 a day. But I like chewable kid's multis. Way cheaper too than regular chewable multis with almost the same potency. Take as many as you need. Gets in your system much easier and not stuck in your esophagus. They have good potency too. One or maybe two max active kids has 25 mg of zinc which is really high for a multi. Why take a pill of zinc.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vjo (Post 17302537)
Thank you. I have long suspected having to drink so much water when you arent thirsty is bs.

Now maybe drinking all that water does some good but yeah it does seem unnatural.

Everyone promoting anything health related has their own slant and line of bs to sell their product.

Selling snake oil hasnt changed much in 150 years. Say or print anything. Just say in fine print, "this not approved by the fda.. bla bla.."

I take 1000mg of chewable C and two chewable Active kids Vites a day. Easy and covers ya.

If your drinking when your thirsty your body has already started to become dehydrated...words of my MD

dyna mo 07-02-2010 12:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302536)
dyna you know whats up! btw, i got that 405x3 deadlift yesterday! felt so good to be back where i was 2 years ago!

:thumbsup that's impressive eh! that's pretty fukcing strong right. this is the phase i just started- get stronger. my new routine is 6-8 rep range, as heavy as possible and i am diggin it! it's crazy going from chest workout of pushups, 25 rep sets, lots of em, great results......to 6 sets of 8 super hard reps and feeling sore for days after. but my strength is increasing super fast, creatine prolly helped that right.

Jon Oso 07-02-2010 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dyna mo (Post 17302390)
it's the #1 nutrient, but didn't y'all have to work up to that amount? i am making progress towards the 1 gallon a day, but i certainly can't just start drinking a gal+ a day.

I've been up for about an hour and I've already drank 2L of water (4 bottles of water).

I have always been able to intake a LOT of fluid, even before I started working out a lot, and since I've stopped I can still drink a gallon of water a day if I really put my mind to it.

I had to work up to drinking 3 gallons + over the course of a few months. I was wearing jeans and 2 shirts in the middle of the summer and not running the a/c in my car so I was constantly sweating, I felt GREAT though.

I was basically drinking 16oz of OJ, half of that mixed with protein and fresh berries, and water. No alcohol, no soda, no other juice other than the occasional smoothie from jamba juice if I was out and needed to cram in some protein (Nothing like asking for 8 extra scoops of their protein powder haha).

BUT, since then I've started smoking, drinking soda again and I have just recently started drinking a lot of water again and I already feel an improvement overall. It's not some miracle life saver but getting hydrated without all the other bullshit is SO much better.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 12:50 PM

when you first get on creatine the strength and endurance increase is amazing, youll start to level off and plateau so keep those cals slightly up do keep progressing. im about to go on a 500 cal deficit and attempt to get down to a 6-7% bf. right now im just about 10%, I need to get some ripped abs then clean bulk up to 180 @ 8% and maintain from there

dyna mo 07-02-2010 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon Oso (Post 17302586)
I've been up for about an hour and I've already drank 2L of water (4 bottles of water).

I have always been able to intake a LOT of fluid, even before I started working out a lot, and since I've stopped I can still drink a gallon of water a day if I really put my mind to it.

I had to work up to drinking 3 gallons + over the course of a few months. I was wearing jeans and 2 shirts in the middle of the summer and not running the a/c in my car so I was constantly sweating, I felt GREAT though.

I was basically drinking 16oz of OJ, half of that mixed with protein and fresh berries, and water. No alcohol, no soda, no other juice other than the occasional smoothie from jamba juice if I was out and needed to cram in some protein (Nothing like asking for 8 extra scoops of their protein powder haha).

BUT, since then I've started smoking, drinking soda again and I have just recently started drinking a lot of water again and I already feel an improvement overall. It's not some miracle life saver but getting hydrated without all the other bullshit is SO much better.

3 gallons is insane! i'm on nothing but water. no fooling.
Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302593)
when you first get on creatine the strength and endurance increase is amazing, youll start to level off and plateau so keep those cals slightly up do keep progressing. im about to go on a 500 cal deficit and attempt to get down to a 6-7% bf. right now im just about 10%, I need to get some ripped abs then clean bulk up to 180 @ 8% and maintain from there

that's kinda why i didn't want to necc stop, might as well ride the gain till i run out which should prolly = same time as plateau eh. fuck, getting to 6-7% man, i know how hard that is.
i think i am going to have to engage in extreme measure to stay at ~7%.

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 01:04 PM

ive been doing interval training 5x5 sets, i choose my body parts, ill do a set of 5 for each part and then run .4 miles until i complete a full 2 miles on top of all my working sets. Pick 5 excersises to do, do 1 set of each, go run, do 1 set of each, go run, etc. No breaks between working sets unless your adding or taking off plates/moving around. That will get your heart rate up!

Vjo 07-02-2010 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WarChild (Post 17301661)

Remember there's two types of water retention. The first is water inside the cells. This is good water, it means your body is properly hydraded. The second is water outside of the cells, which in excess amounts causes bloating.

Interesting. Do you (or anyone) know of any good over the counter products/ect or methods besides cutting salt that help flush excess water.

I think this is my prob too as well as the OP who it appears has put on water weight. I need to cut down or eliminate table salt and salty foods for sure.

I notice if I get a little more sleep and urinate a couple more times the weight goes down quite a bit more. So water retention is a big factor in weight control. Our bodies seem to want to flush water when we sleep.

I know if you have high blood pressure (which usually goes up with weight gain) docs will put you on diuretics to get rid of water. But I would rather use some kind of natural method or otc substance if possible to flush excess water weight.

Edit: Maybe I need to drink more water weird as that seems. :)

Choopa Phil 07-02-2010 01:19 PM

vjo, drink more it will diloute the salt content in your body therefore flushing you out more. I wouldnt suggest a diuretic just for the hell of it

The Demon 07-02-2010 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302460)
creatine forces more water into the muscle cells not ontop of and inbetween muscle fibers, it will not take away from that shredded look unless your going out for a competition.

You don't get a shredded look in creatine unless you're drinking plenty of water.

The Demon 07-02-2010 01:24 PM

[QUOTE=DLXphil;17302531]
Quote:

Originally Posted by mgtarheels (Post 17302525)

yes bloated from overdosing...i can connect the dots. OK creatine does cause bloat in MEGA DOSES! Taken in a normal dosage scheme which hes not doing currently will yeild zero bloat

Ignore Mgtarheels. He'll come on here once in a while making random shit up and acting like he knows what he's talking about. THen someone kicks his ass and he disappears again.

Major (Tom) 07-02-2010 01:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302435)
yea because steroids are miracles and take the place of hard work and diet? Tren is one helluva harsh compound, a lot of guys start sweating yellow and brown because of it, not to mention you get very little sleep while on something like that. Test is best, but its not needed for what dyna is trying to accomplish. Theres no need to shut down natural test production by introducing exogenous hormones to the body

Tren acetate is the bad one. The others are much safe. tren hex, tren enth.
ds

Vjo 07-02-2010 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302677)
vjo, drink more it will diloute the salt content in your body therefore flushing you out more. I wouldnt suggest a diuretic just for the hell of it

Thanks really appreciate it. Yes it is coming together now. I have always added table salt and that may be bloating me more than I thought. I will eliminate it for at least a week and drink more water. Easier this time of year.

I am sure drinking more water is good. Perhaps there is excess in anything. But drinking a fair amount more for a week with no added salt and no corn chips (which come to think, I eat a lot of) ect is a good test. :)

How to do right to our bodies is sometimes the last thing we get figured out. :)

Vjo 07-02-2010 01:53 PM

True story relating to water weight.. and just to show you all some extremes and how uninformed my gen is or was..

When Diet Coke came out in 1981 I started drinking it which is when my weight slowly started going up in retrospect. I am sure now it was water weight. The bodies reaction to this chemical.

Anyhow, I drank nothing but Diet Coke almost exclusively until about 2002. I mean nothing all day and all night for over 20 years but diet coke. I even had a 12 pack in the car. I know crazy. We didnt know better. :) I mean I knew it was odd but i was raised on soda so figured diet soda would be ok. :)

In those days there was no bottled spring water but maybe one brand in the back of the store cooler. Noone drank it. We all drank pop mostly.

In 2002 I literally began to taste formaldehyde inside me. A by product from the digestion of aspartame I learned and finally woke up.

I quit cold turkey and drink tap or bottled spring now exclusively.

icymelon 07-02-2010 02:00 PM

it causes you to retain water. you dont want to do it too long. that stuff stays in your blood for a while. you probably could stop for a while. if you dont feel good then you absolutely should stop. and you will still have the beni from it just hit the gym consistently for the next 6 weeks you should make some gains

mgtarheels 07-02-2010 02:07 PM

[QUOTE=The Demon;17302693]
Quote:

Originally Posted by DLXphil (Post 17302531)

Ignore Mgtarheels. He'll come on here once in a while making random shit up and acting like he knows what he's talking about. THen someone kicks his ass and he disappears again.

Shit troll is shit.

PenisFace 07-02-2010 02:59 PM

Dude fuck, quit using supplements. All they do is empty your wallet and make you feel like a big sack of shit. There's only one supplement I take. Whey protein. And even then, I prefer to get my protein from real food. I start my day with a protein shake with breakfast, and that's it. After working out I have chicken breast and a potato. Supplements won't make you big, they'll make your bank account small.

MUSCLE TECH. REAL SCIENCE. REAL RESULTS.*






*No scientists were involved in the making of this product. It is made of old chinese news papers and the "clinical studies" did not occur. Furthermore, we are theives. Thanks for your money, chump. Fuck the FDA.

maccsta 07-02-2010 03:12 PM

Maximum amount of lean muscle that you can put on in a month is 0.9kg (1.98lbs) and that's with the perfect conditons ie protein and perfect bb program

You can increase this amount 5 fold with steroids 4.5kg (10lbs)!!!

So you've got lots of water retention and fat in that 12lbs you put on ;)

dyna mo 07-02-2010 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maccsta (Post 17303077)
Maximum amount of lean muscle that you can put on in a month is 0.9kg (1.98lbs) and that's with the perfect conditons ie protein and perfect bb program

You can increase this amount 5 fold with steroids 4.5kg (10lbs)!!!

So you've got lots of water retention and fat in that 12lbs you put on ;)

it's not fat, my caliper measurements, etc haven't gone up. i understand it's water weight, that's what creatine does.
besides, you can't put fat on much faster than you can put muscle on, so if put the max 2 pounds fat on this week,i will have almost doubled the amount of excess body fat i have!

:thumbsup

maccsta 07-02-2010 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dyna mo (Post 17303092)
it's not fat, my caliper measurements, etc haven't gone up. i understand it's water weight, that's what creatine does.
besides, you can't put fat on much faster than you can put muscle on, so if put the max 2 pounds fat on this week,i will have almost doubled the amount of excess body fat i have!

:thumbsup

Yeah man it's water retention, time to start juicing ;)

On a serious note, bb is a very very slow process, 2lbs a month is fuck all for the amount of effort you put in. So 1 week of water retention shouldn't hold you back, think month by month. And think of serious muscle growth over a year.

PenisFace 07-02-2010 03:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maccsta (Post 17303130)
Yeah man it's water retention, time to start juicing ;)

On a serious note, bb is a very very slow process, 2lbs a month is fuck all for the amount of effort you put in. So 1 week of water retention shouldn't hold you back, think month by month. And think of serious muscle growth over a year.

Creatine makes you hold water like a mother fucker. I felt like I was going to die when I tried it several years ago. Never again


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
©2000-, AI Media Network Inc