Iphone 3GS Worth Upgrading?

[Blazed]

I dropped my Iphone 3G today for about the 5th time and this time it broke.

So i either pay to get it repaired or just buy a 3GS, for those who had a 3G and now have a 3GS is the phone that much better? Since getting it repaired is $300, if i buy a 3GS its around $750.

[Evil Chris]

I have a 2G still and if it busted, I'd go for the 3GS for sure.

[tical]

3GS for 750? wow that is crazy

[Choopa Phil]

not a chance, i have a 3g and the network still doesnt do MMS, ie the phone is capable but the network isnt ready for it. WTF, i switched from verizon cause ATT is supposed to be better with this stuff!

[Blazed]

Originally Posted by Evil Chris

I have a 2G still and if it busted, I'd go for the 3GS for sure.

I can see that because the 3GS is a massive leap up from the 2G, but from the 3G?

Originally Posted by DLXphil

not a chance, i have a 3g and the network still doesnt do MMS, ie the phone is capable but the network isnt ready for it. WTF, i switched from verizon cause ATT is supposed to be better with this stuff!

Over here the network (O2) does MMS as well as tethering, i think its only AT&T that doesnt.

[Persius]

How exactly is this broken. Let me know

[Blazed]

Originally Posted by Persius

How exactly is this broken. Let me know

The touch screen doesnt work.

[candyflip]

But a used 3G on eBay or CL for under $200 if you look.

[niche25]

I went from 2g to 3gs and its like night and day.

[bbm]

it is cool

[96ukssob]

see if you eligible for an upgrade with AT&T. if not, ask them for the "discount rate" and you can get a 16GB for $399 instead of $599 ($200 off)

[Blazed]

Originally Posted by candyflip

But a used 3G on eBay or CL for under $200 if you look.

Cheapest i can find a used 3G that isnt damaged on ebay is £270, around $450. Im in the UK.

[NetHorse]

I upgraded the software on my 3G and love it. The cut & paste, search and wide keyboard are awesome changes. I also like the updated youtube function. The 3GS has video, which is cool, but I'm not going to be upgrading anytime soon.

Originally Posted by DLXphil

not a chance, i have a 3g and the network still doesnt do MMS, ie the phone is capable but the network isnt ready for it. WTF, i switched from verizon cause ATT is supposed to be better with this stuff!

I've had ATT for awhile, my old 3G razor had picture MMS. Supposedly AT&T is releasing another software update sometime in July for picture MMS. I use the facebook APP which allows me to upload pics from my phone so I don't really care.

[k0nr4d]

grab the HTC touch pro 2, i just got it and its 100x better then the iphone

[tranza]

I'm still looking for one to buy...

[Officer]

Just got my 3G back in March. DL'd the 3.0 update over the weekend. The new functions are nice! I never used the video cam or the voice dialing with any other phone I've ever had so those would be useless to me. the 3G with 3.0 is enough for me I guess, definitely not worth the money to upgrade if you are happy with your 3G imho.

[Mr Bond]

I just went from a 3G to the 3GS

There is a Sweet Speed increase that was noticable from the first time I touched one in the store. Some apps are way faster... some.. there is only like a 1 second difference. I'm just a personl user (don't use any business apps) but I'm Really Happy with the phone(the 3GS over the 3G).

3GS VS 3G. Running both phones side by side and touching/activating apps at the exact same time(withing my human ability)

- Safari Web Browsing: 5-6 seconds faster and a lot smoother
- GPS Maps: 4-5 seconds faster and a lot smoother
- Viewing YouTube and other Media Lists that load thumbnails:
-- 2-3 seconds faster to load lists
-- Faster and smoother play of videos
-- jumping time points in videos smoother and faster

- View Contacts List: 2-3 seconds faster
- View a Contact: 1 second faster
- Opening/Activating camera: 1 second faster
- All other apps open, close and operate about 1-2 seconds faster

* The Keyboard is Much Smoother... dose not pause at all like the 3G does at times.


I was not eligible for early upgrade/new customer pricing I would have had to pay 400(16GB) or 500(32GB) for an early upgrade.

* But I Got it Anyway!

Heres what I did,

I went direct to an apple store. Apple stores can only activate NEW Accounts as if you are a New customer (because they get comission on it). Adding a 2nd line at an apple store also costs $20/Month (instead of $10/Month that Att Charges... again because they get comission).

They won't let the phone leave the store without a contract unless you pay full pricing (like 700 USD).

So, I activated on a new separate plan and got the discounted pricing.

The I went to an att store and switched the numbers so I could get my old number over to my new 3GS.

Then I called ATT customer service/relations and "Selected Disconnect My Service" as if I was going to leave or do an early termination on my old 3G. They offered me a shared plan at 49.00 (normally 59.00) and a 2nd line at $10.

Now I have 2 iPhones and I'm only paying an extra $40 (but it would be $60 extra per Month if I did not get the 49.00 shared plan that only att Reps in the Disconnect department can offer... and the $10 less for the 2nd line that only ATT direct can offer(not the apple store)

OK so $40 a month extra because any iPhone on the ATT Net - MUST have a Data Plan at $30/Month (theres no bypassing it because the ATT network will recognise an iPhone by its IMEI/Serial number.

But, you can SWAP off the IMEI/Serial number to another phone that is not an iPhone... and Drop the data plan. Just buy a $5 broken phone off of ebay and use the IMEI number from that. I just so happen to have an old black berry that I will use. Then I can drop the data plan. This Keeps both Phone Numbers - ACTIVE.. and subsequently does Not breech contract with ATT (if you do breech contract they will charge you the full price of the phone). All att Contracts are tied to the phone number.


Now that sounds like a lot.. but its not. I saved $200 and all I did was

- Go direct to an Apple Store
- make 3 phone calls to ATT.
- Switch an IMEI number.

My monthly bill comes out to Exactly what I was paying before....


Mr.Bond

[Max - RiotDesign]

I'm still on my original 2G and I don't see any good reasons to upgrade, but if my 2G broke or something I'd give the Palm Pre a try

[LiveDose]

Originally Posted by k0nr4d

grab the HTC touch pro 2, i just got it and its 100x better then the iphone

I have the Touch Pro. What did they change?

[Persius]

Originally Posted by Blazed

The touch screen doesnt work.

There are plenty of people that will still buy it.. post it on ebay or craigslist, (if you have that in your area)

I sold my iphone 2g with 4gb broken dented edges and crack onscreen for 100$